In MLB The Show 26, the new Bobby Witt Takeover Program is one of those content drops that looks simple on the surface but quietly rewards efficient grinding and MLB The Show 26 Stubs. Centered around a 93 overall Cover Athlete version of Bobby Witt Jr., this program isn’t necessarily flashy in terms of rewards, but it does offer a solid mid-game card, useful progression XP, and some stub value for relatively straightforward gameplay.

The catch? You’ll need 70 stars to complete the program, and while that sounds like a lot, most of it is designed to be completed passively as you play. The real challenge is understanding how to structure your grind so you don’t waste time repeating inefficient modes or ignoring stacked progress opportunities.

This guide breaks down every requirement, explains the smartest ways to complete each objective, and gives you a clear roadmap to finishing the program as quickly as possible.

Overview of the Bobby Witt Takeover Program

The Takeover program sits in the “normal themed” content tab. Compared to larger seasonal grinds, it’s relatively compact:

Earn 70 total stars

Complete 7 missions/tasks

Unlock a 93 OVR Bobby Witt Cover Athlete card

Earn bonus stubs and XP along the way

Most players will find that a large portion of progress happens naturally through regular gameplay. However, the structure of the missions—especially the locked “career highlights” chain—means efficiency matters more than ever.

The reward card itself is solid but not game-breaking. In fact, it closely resembles the Live Series version of Bobby Witt Jr., with only minor differences in attributes. If you already own his Live Series card or aren’t focused on collections, the Takeover version is a perfectly fine substitute.

The Star System Explained

To unlock the final reward, you need 70 stars total, earned through completing program missions. These missions fall into two major categories:

Passive accumulation tasks

Structured mission chains (Career Highlights)

The passive tasks are designed to be completed while you play normally. The structured missions, however, require you to follow a specific order.

This is where most players will lose time if they don’t plan ahead.

Passive Progress Missions (Do These While Playing Anything)

Two of the easiest objectives in the program are:

1. 7,000 PXP with Any Players

This is purely passive. Every game mode contributes:

Ranked

Conquest

Mini Seasons

Play vs CPU

Diamond Dynasty events

You don’t need to focus on this at all. It will naturally complete if you’re playing regularly.

2. 60 Total Bases with Any Players

Again, this is fully passive and stacks with normal gameplay. Every hit contributes:

Single = 1 base

Double = 2 bases

Triple = 3 bases

Home run = 4 bases

If you’re grinding PXP efficiently, this will finish alongside it.

Strategy Tip:

Use this opportunity to stack progress with lineup choices. Don’t overthink it—just use players you’re comfortable hitting with rather than chasing specific card types.

The Career Highlights Chain (The Real Grind)

The most important—and slightly controversial—part of this program is the locked mission chain system.

Instead of letting you complete all missions simultaneously, the game forces you to complete them in sequence. This means:

You cannot progress multiple objectives at once

Each completed task unlocks the next

Efficiency depends on lineup and mode choice

This structure slows down multitasking but encourages focused grinding.

Known Mission Types (Based on Structure)

While only the first mission is fully visible at the start, the rest follow predictable baseball stat categories:

15 Hits (Any Players)

Likely Extra-Base Hits

Likely Home Runs (based on “30-30 season” reference)

Likely Stolen Bases mission

Additional hitting-focused objectives

Each mission is straightforward in wording, but the sequencing makes them feel longer than they actually are.

How to Complete Missions Efficiently

The key to finishing this program quickly is not raw gameplay—it’s lineup construction and mode selection.

1. Build a “Progression Lineup”

Instead of your best team, use players that:

Have high power for home runs

Have speed for stolen bases

Have strong contact for consistent hits

This ensures you are always working toward multiple mission types at once.

2. Play Modes That Maximize Plate Appearances

Best options:

Mini Seasons (fast games, consistent ABs)

Conquest (multi-objective grinding)

Play vs CPU on rookie or veteran difficulty

Avoid long-form competitive modes if your goal is efficiency.

3. Don’t Over-Specialize Too Early

Since missions unlock sequentially, don’t build your entire lineup around stolen bases or power immediately. Wait until later stages before optimizing for a single stat type.

Breaking Down Each Mission Type Strategy

Even though the exact hidden missions aren’t fully visible upfront, their structure is predictable. Here’s how to approach each likely category.

Hits Mission

Focus:

High contact hitters

Short swings, line-drive builds

Best approach:

Play low difficulty CPU games

Prioritize singles over power swings

Extra-Base Hits Mission

Focus:

Gap power hitters

Fast players who can stretch doubles

Best approach:

Use hitter-friendly stadiums

Aim for doubles rather than home runs early

Home Run / Power Mission

Focus:

High power ratings (90+)

Pull-side swing timing

Best approach:

Play in small stadiums

Use directional hitting if needed

Stolen Bases Mission

Focus:

85+ speed players

Good baserunning attributes

Best approach:

Take early pitches

Steal on predictable CPU patterns

Avoid risky double steals unless confident

Why the Locked Structure Matters

The decision to lock missions in sequence is unusual for MLB The Show 26. Traditionally, Takeover or program-style content allows parallel completion, which lets players naturally stack progress.

Here, the design forces a linear grind path, which has both positives and negatives:

Pros:

Clear direction

No confusion about what to do next

Structured progression pacing

Cons:

Slower overall completion

No multitasking efficiency

Forces repeated game modes

Most players will find it slightly restrictive, especially compared to older program designs.

Is the Bobby Witt Card Worth It?

The final reward is a 93 overall version of Bobby Witt Jr., positioned as a Cover Athlete-style card.

Strengths:

Balanced hitting stats

Strong speed and defense combination

Versatile in multiple lineups

Weaknesses:

Very similar to Live Series version

Not a major upgrade for endgame squads

Limited long-term value if you already own Witt

Recommendation:

Worth it if you are early/mid game

Optional if you already have elite shortstops

Skip if you’re focused only on meta endgame builds

Bonus Rewards and Hidden Value

Even if the card itself isn’t revolutionary, the program still provides:

Stubs (small but useful)

XP progression toward seasonal rewards

Free Team Affinity packs (via shop content)

Jersey unlocks that contribute toward collections

These side rewards make the grind more worthwhile than it first appears.

Efficiency Tips to Finish Faster

If you want to complete the program in the shortest time possible:

Combine PXP grinding with hits missions

Use Mini Seasons for fast repetition

Avoid switching lineups too often

Focus on multi-hit innings rather than home run hunting early

Save stolen base grinding for dedicated sessions

The biggest mistake players make is overthinking each mission instead of letting progress stack naturally.

Final Thoughts

The Bobby Witt Takeover Program in MLB The Show 26 is a straightforward but slightly restrictive grind. While the rewards aren’t game-changing, the structure encourages consistent gameplay and rewards players who optimize their time efficiently.

If you treat it as a background progression system rather than a focused grind, buy MLB The Show 26 Stubs, you’ll likely complete it without even realizing it. But if you try to rush it without planning, the locked mission structure can slow you down significantly.

Ultimately, it’s a solid mid-tier program: not essential, not useless—just a clean, structured path to a usable 93 overall card and some bonus progression along the way.